Acquisitions · · 3 min read
Buy or Build? How I Decide Whether to Acquire a Business or Start From Scratch
Buying a business buys you time. It can also buy you someone else's problems. The work is knowing which one you're getting.

I've built most of what I own from scratch. Royal Rentals started with one car and a lot of late nights. Credit Cure grew out of my own credit journey. Starting from zero taught me nearly everything I know about operating.
As my focus has shifted toward global acquisitions, land and new construction, I spend more time on a different question: should we build this, or buy something that already exists? There's no universal answer. But there is a set of questions I ask every time. This is my personal framework, for education only, and not an offer of any investment or security.
What am I actually paying for?
When you buy a business, you're not just buying assets. You're buying some mix of customers, people, systems, reputation, contracts, location and time. Before I talk price, I want to know which of those things are real and which are assumptions.
If the value lives mostly in the owner's personal relationships, and the owner is leaving, I may be paying for something that walks out the door at closing.
How much time does buying save?
Time is the most common reason to buy. A business with existing customers, licenses and trained staff can be years ahead of a startup. That head start has real value. I try to estimate it honestly: how long would it take me to build the same thing, and what would it cost to get there? If the answer is six months and modest spending, paying a big premium makes less sense.
What problems am I inheriting?
Every existing business has history. Some of it is great. Some of it isn't visible until you're inside. Deferred maintenance, unhappy employees, tax issues, customer complaints, outdated equipment and informal agreements all transfer in some form. Diagnosing before you spend is something I learned as a mechanic, and it's exactly why the mechanic's mindset applies to acquisitions too.
Do the systems exist outside the owner's head?
A business that runs because one person holds it together is fragile. I want to see written processes, clean books, documented pricing and roles that don't depend on a single individual. If those don't exist, the business may still be worth buying, but the price should reflect the work it'll take to build them.
Who's staying?
People are often the most valuable part of a deal. Key employees, managers and long-time vendors carry knowledge that isn't in any document. I want to understand who's committed to staying, what they need and how the transition will feel from their side.
What does the structure look like?
How a deal is structured matters as much as the price. Cash at close, seller financing, earn-outs and transition periods all shift risk between buyer and seller. I've written about who gets paid first in a deal. Understanding that order is essential before signing anything, and I always want qualified legal and tax advisors involved.
When building wins
Building often makes more sense when the market is new, when no existing business fits your standards, when the culture you need would be hard to change, or when the asking prices don't reflect reality. Building is slower, but you control every decision from the first day.
When buying wins
Buying often makes more sense when timing matters, when licenses or locations are hard to get, when there's a strong team in place and when the seller is motivated to support a real transition.
Willing to walk
The most important part of my framework is being willing to say no. I've passed on deals that looked exciting because the answers didn't hold up. Walking away is part of the strategy, not a failure of it.
Buy or build, the goal is the same: own something that runs well, serves people well and still makes sense ten years from now.